The Archive
Reference Library
The founding document as written, a plain overview of the seven Articles, and a glossary of archaic and legal terms.
Judicial Power & Separation of Powers
Printz v. United States
Decided: 1997
Anti-commandeering: the federal government cannot conscript state or local officials to enforce federal regulatory programs.
The Brady Handgun Violence Prevention Act required local sheriffs to run background checks on handgun purchasers pending a national database. Sheriffs Printz and Mack objected that this dragooned state officers into federal service. Justice Scalia's opinion for the Court extended the anti-commandeering principle of New York v. United States (1992) from state legislatures to state executive officers. Federal law may regulate individuals directly, and it may induce state cooperation through spending or preemption, but it may not compel state officials to administer federal programs. The dual-sovereignty structure of the Constitution — reinforced by the Tenth Amendment — forbids it. Printz is a foundational federalism precedent and was the analytical backbone of Murphy v. NCAA (2018) striking down the federal sports-betting ban.