EXPLORE YOUR U. S. CONSTITUTION

The Archive

Reference Library

The founding document as written, a plain overview of the seven Articles, and a glossary of archaic and legal terms.

Back to Supreme Court Rulings

Judicial Power & Separation of Powers

Gravel v. United States

Decided: 1972

In brief

The Speech or Debate Clause protects legislative acts and legislative aides, but not private republication of classified material.

The Court's ruling in depth

After Senator Mike Gravel read portions of the Pentagon Papers into a subcommittee record and arranged their private publication, a grand jury sought to question his aide. Justice White's opinion held that the Speech or Debate Clause of Article I, § 6 shields members and their aides from being 'questioned in any other place' about legislative acts — but it does not extend to Gravel's arrangement with a private publisher, which was not part of the legislative function. Gravel is the leading modern authority on the reach of legislative immunity and on what counts as a protected 'legislative act.'

[ Sponsor Ad Placeholder ]